|BRIEF RESEARCH ARTICLE
|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 154-156
Mortality due to mass Hymenoptera attacks: A serious but underrecognized public health problem in a mountainous state of India
Sanjay Vikrant1, Ajay Jaryal1, Anupam Parashar2
1 Professor and Head, Assistant Professor, Department of Nephrology, Indira Gandhi Medical College, Shimla, Himachal Pradesh, India
2 Professor, Department of Community Medicine, Indira Gandhi Medical College, Shimla, Himachal Pradesh, India
|Date of Web Publication||18-Jun-2019|
Department of Nephrology, Indira Gandhi Medical College, Shimla - 171 001, Himachal Pradesh
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Most deaths related to Hymenoptera are a result of immediate hypersensitivity reactions causing anaphylaxis to one or few stings. However, if the patient is exposed to a large quantity of the venom due to mass/multiple stings, massive envenomation can cause death in nonallergic individuals. Thirty-nine cases of acute kidney injury (AKI) who followed mass attacks by Hymenoptera were seen over 15 years, with a reference period between 2003 and 2017. AKI was severe; most (85%) of them required dialysis and one-third died. Mass attacks by Hymenoptera have become a serious public health problem in tropics. There is no antivenom, and treatment in such cases is supportive. Early hospitalization is vital to reduce morbidity and mortality.
Keywords: Hymenoptera, mass envenomation, mortality, tropics
|How to cite this article:|
Vikrant S, Jaryal A, Parashar A. Mortality due to mass Hymenoptera attacks: A serious but underrecognized public health problem in a mountainous state of India. Indian J Public Health 2019;63:154-6
|How to cite this URL:|
Vikrant S, Jaryal A, Parashar A. Mortality due to mass Hymenoptera attacks: A serious but underrecognized public health problem in a mountainous state of India. Indian J Public Health [serial online] 2019 [cited 2022 Oct 6];63:154-6. Available from: https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2019/63/2/154/260599
Animal envenomations cause over 100,000 deaths each year worldwide. Most of these deaths occur in tropical countries and are due to snakebite, scorpion stings, and anaphylactic reactions to insect stings. Insects that sting to defend their colonies belong to the order Hymenoptera. There are two major subgroups: vespids include the yellow jacket, hornet, and wasp and apids include the honeybee and bumblebee. The stinging apparatus is used as a defense if the insect is disturbed. The stinger is detached from the body after a single sting by the honeybee, and it dies after that. However, a single wasp is capable of stinging multiple times as the stinger is not separated from the body after the sting. This finding is useful to differentiate honeybee from wasp, as wasps do not leave the stinger on the victim's skin.,, Hymenoptera toxins are complex mixtures of peptides, enzymes, proteins, and chemicals, and they cause cellular injury via several mechanisms. Despite the differences in venom composition and quantity released per sting, they lead to similar medical consequences, such as localized normal allergic reactions, mild-to-severe anaphylaxis and shock, and multiple-organ and tissue injury leading to multiple-organ failure. The sting becomes clinically significant if the patient has an allergy to Hymenoptera venom or if the patient is exposed to a large quantity of the venom due to mass/multiple stings. Most deaths related to Hymenoptera stings are the result of immediate hypersensitivity reactions causing anaphylaxis. However, death may also occur from severe local reactions, particularly if involving the airways with subsequent respiratory obstruction. Massive envenomation during swarm attacks can likewise cause death in nonallergic individuals. The sting incidents are high during late summer or early fall when there is an increased outdoor activity of human beings or a large number of vespids are attracted to the foods of humans eating outdoors. The sting or mass envenomation occurs if the insect is disturbed or its hive is interrupted. It is an occupational hazard of farmers, and victims are usually adults of productive age group in rural areas of tropics. Little has been written in the medical literature about mass Hymenoptera stings in India, where many such incidents have occurred in recent years. Therefore, this study was planned with an objective to report mortality due to mass Hymenoptera attacks.
It was a retrospective study in which the secondary data of the patients admitted at Indira Gandhi Medical College Hospital, Shimla, with animal envenomation-induced acute kidney injury (AKI) were analyzed, with a reference period between 2003 and 2017. The diagnosis of animal envenomation was based on clinical history and findings on physical examination of bite or sting marks. The medical records were evaluated for patient information on demographic factors, type of animal bite or sting, history, and clinical characteristics. Outcomes of the requirement of dialysis, survival, and mortality were analyzed. Continuous data were expressed as mean ± standard deviation, and the means were compared using an unpaired t- test. Nominal data were expressed as frequencies or proportions, and the Chi-square test and Fisher's exact test were used to compare the differences in frequency between the groups. The hospital is the only tertiary care hospital in the whole of the state providing nephrology services, and the data capture was complete. The institute ethics committee approved the study.
There were 181 cases (141 snakebites, 36 wasp stings, 3 bee stings, and 1 monitor lizard) of AKI due to venomous animals [Table 1]. Twenty-seven (14.9%) patients died. Thirty-nine cases of AKI followed mass attacks by Hymenoptera [Table 2]. All patients were from rural areas, and most were farmers in the working age group. Thirty-three (91.7%) patients with wasp sting-induced AKI required dialysis, whereas none with that due to bee stings required dialysis. Thirteen (33%) patients with AKI who followed mass Hymenoptera attacks died. There was no significant difference in the demographic characteristics of survival and nonsurvival groups. Mortality following wasp sings was 36.1% as compared to that of 9.2% due to snakebite (P = 0.001).
|Table 1: Mortality due to venomous animals in a tertiary care hospital in the state of Himachal Pradesh: 2003-2017|
Click here to view
|Table 2: Mortality due to mass Hymenoptera attacks in a tertiary care hospital in the state of Himachal Pradesh: 2003-2017|
Click here to view
Further, 13 cases of multiple wasp stings were reported to the health department in the state during 2017. These incidents reportedly occurred in the circumstances leading to interruption of the vespid hive. One patient died at a secondary care hospital possibly due to anaphylaxis. Three patients were admitted to our hospital due to AKI following multiple wasp stings. Two of the three patients died, one died due to recurrent hyperkalemia, and another succumbed to the complication of acute respiratory distress syndrome.
Attacks by multiple Hymenoptera (i.e., mass envenomations) have become a serious public health problem in recent years in many developing countries. Accidents due to massive attack with hundreds or thousands of Africanized bees are well known in Latin America. Because of their aggressive behavior and the number of accidents associated with them, the Africanized bees are also known as “killer bees.” Accidents due to multiple wasp stings have been reported from countries such as China, India, Vietnam, Thailand, Malaysia, and Nepal.,,,,,, AKI or death may result from 10 to 200 wasp stings or 150–1000 bee stings. Multiple stings result in a unique syndrome of intravascular hemolysis, rhabdomyolysis, AKI, and hepatitis. More than half of the victims who experience multiple wasps or bee stings develop AKI due to intravascular hemolysis, rhabdomyolysis, shock, and the direct toxic effects of the venom. Most patients require dialysis, and the reported mortality ranged from 9.1% to 50%.,,,,,, Overall mortality among an aggregate of 295 cases who developed AKI following multiple Hymenoptera stings was 19%.
Xie et al. reported 1091 cases of wasp stings over 3 years from Hubei Province, China, with a population of 60 million. Most (76.9%) of the cases had ten or more stings, and the inhospital mortality was 5.1%. Forty-eight patients died of organ injury following toxic reactions to the stings, whereas six died from anaphylactic shock. The inhospital mortality in patients with >10 stings was higher than that of ≤10 stings (5.2% vs. 1.0%, P = 0.02). Mortality observed in the study was 0.9 per million of the population.
There is no antivenom for Hymenoptera stings. Therefore, treatment in all patients with multiple stinging is supportive. Early hospitalization is important to reduce morbidity and mortality. Hymenoptera may cause both obstructive and toxic acute renal failure, in part due to hemolysis and rhabdomyolysis, resulting in the release of myoglobin and hemoglobin from myocytes and erythrocytes, respectively. All such patients should be hospitalized for aggressive hydration and urine alkalinization to prevent the AKI secondary to hemolysis and rhabdomyolysis. Provided medical intervention is timely along with the supportive therapy; there is a complete recovery of the kidney function.
Limitation of our study is that some patients might have been missed because of referral outside the state, especially for those residing in bordering areas. However, our hospital being the only tertiary care hospital in a mountainous state for nephrology services and getting the referral from all parts of the state, the capture of cases was nearly complete.
In conclusion, Hymenoptera stings pose a common environmental hazard in tropical countries. Mass attacks by Hymenoptera have become a serious but underrecognized public health problem. There is no antivenom, and treatment in such cases is supportive. Early hospitalization is vital to reduce morbidity and mortality. Aggressive hydration and urine alkalinization are advised to prevent the AKI secondary to hemolysis and rhabdomyolysis. There is an urgent need to create awareness in public for seeking medical care in such cases.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
World Health Organization. Weekly Epidemiological Record Poisonous Animal Bites and Stings. World Health Organization; 02 February, 2002. Available from: http://www.who.int/iris/handle/10665/229584
. [Last accessed on 2018 Apr 29].
Vetter RS, Visscher PK, Camazine S. Mass envenomations by honey bees and wasps. West J Med 1999;170:223-7.
Bridi RA, Balbi AL, Neves PM, Ponce D. Acute kidney injury after massive attack of africanised bees. BMJ Case Rep 2014;2014. pii: bcr2013201381.
Thiruventhiran T, Goh BL, Leong CL, Cheah PL, Looi LM, Tan SY, et al.
Acute renal failure following multiple wasp stings. Nephrol Dial Transplant 1999;14:214-7.
Wiwanitkit V. Renal failure from wasp stings: An appraisal on the previous reported Thai cases. Nephrology (Carlton) 2005;10:537.
Vachvanichsanong P, Dissaneewate P. Acute renal failure following wasp sting in children. Eur J Pediatr 2009;168:991-4.
Xuan BH, Mai HL, Thi TX, Thi MT, Nguyen HN, Rabenou RA, et al.
Swarming hornet attacks: Shock and acute kidney injury – A large case series from Vietnam. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2010;25:1146-50.
Sigdel MR, Raut KB. Wasp bite in a referral hospital in Nepal. J Nepal Health Res Counc 2013;11:244-50.
Vikrant S, Parashar A. Two cases of acute kidney injury due to multiple wasp stings. Wilderness Environ Med 2017;28:249-52.
Xie C, Xu S, Ding F, Xie M, Lv J, Yao J, et al.
Clinical features of severe wasp sting patients with dominantly toxic reaction: Analysis of 1091 cases. PLoS One 2013;8:e83164.
[Table 1], [Table 2]
|This article has been cited by|
||Subcutaneous Calcification at Honeybee Sting Site
| ||Diptirekha Satapathy, Thirunavukkarasu Arun Babu |
| ||Indian Pediatrics. 2022; 59(6): 506 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Clinical effects and factors associated with adverse clinical outcomes of hymenopteran stings treated in a Thai Poison Centre: a retrospective cross-sectional study
| ||Praopilad Srisuwarn,Sahaphume Srisuma,Charuwan Sriapha,Achara Tongpoo,Panee Rittilert,Aimon Pradoo,Yuvadee Tanpudsa,Winai Wananukul |
| ||Clinical Toxicology. 2021; : 1 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Flagging positive images for sting wasps: the use of vespine wasps in Guiyang City, China and its conservation implications
| ||C. Dai,S. Chen,X. Wang |
| ||Journal of Insects as Food and Feed. 2021; : 1 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|